Computer Co. Says PTAB Institution Process Unconstitutional

In the News   ·   04 January 2022

Overview

The article describes Arbor Global’s constitutional challenge to how the PTAB decides whether to institute patent reviews.

Patents involved

Arbor sought director review after Samsung proceedings invalidated three patents, filing three petitions in December.

Arguments presented

The company relied on the Appointments Clause, the Administrative Procedure Act and the America Invents Act, drawing an analogy with the Supreme Court’s Arthrex decision.

Requested change

Arbor proposed that the USPTO director make institution decisions rather than delegate that authority. The source reports the company’s arguments; it does not establish that a court accepted them or that the challenged procedure was invalidated.